Rentaka Defence Portal
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Gunroom Store

US Navy, OSD Battle Over LCS Future

20/1/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
The first of class littoral combat ships USS Freedom (LCS 1), rear, and USS Independence (LCS 2) maneuver together during an exercise off the coast of Southern California. (Photo: US Navy)
By: Christopher P. Cavas (www.defensenews.com)

The contentious question of how many littoral combat ships to build has been batted back and forth this year between the US Navy’s top leadership and senior Pentagon leaders. By the end of the day on Jan. 17, a certain kind of standoff appears to have been reached, foregoing — for the moment — a final decision.

The result could be a compromise. Reportedly, LCS is being put on something of a probation: The buy would be limited to 26 or 28 ships — the exact number couldn’t be confirmed by press time — but the ship will need to pass evaluation by the Pentagon’s Office of the Director, Operational Test and Evaluation (DOT&E) before further ship buys can proceed, according to multiple Pentagon sources, who stressed that no final decisions have been reached.

The first salvo of the year was fired Jan. 6 by Christine Fox, acting deputy defense secretary, when, in a classified memo, she directed the Navy to halt LCS production after 32 ships and begin development of a “more capable surface combatant.”

Navy officials have strenuously defended the service’s plan to build a total of 52 of the small, fast and adaptable ships. Three are in service, with a fourth set to join the fleet in April. Another 20 ships are under construction or on order.

Navy leaders fought back almost immediately. Service staff members argued with the Office of the Secretary of Defense (OSD) to keep the status quo of 52 ships.

Fox is one of the key people within OSD urging a severe cutback of the LCS program, if not outright cancellation. She often questioned the combat effectiveness of the program in her previous position as director of the Pentagon’s Office of Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation.

A Jan. 15 Defense News web story detailing the decision to cap the ships at 32 set off a renewed round of events inside the Pentagon last week. Navy Secretary Ray Mabus personally argued his case before Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel and Fox that evening, urging the program’s continuation, Pentagon sources confirmed.

A similar probation was issued in January 2011 by then-Defense Secretary Robert Gates regarding the F-35B version of the joint strike fighter. The probation was lifted in January 2012 — short of the two years Gates initially declared — after program performance improved.

Neither the Navy nor OSD would confirm an agreement by close of business on Jan. 17.

DOT&E routinely criticizes the LCS program, irked in particular by the Navy’s 2010 decision to take the first ship out of the normal testing cycle and instead send it to sea. As the first of a new ship class, the service was anxious to get underway time rather than keep it in a rigorous testing cycle.

The 2012 DOT&E report noted concerns about the ship’s survivability, writing that “it is not expected to maintain mission capability after taking a significant hit in a hostile combat environment.” There was no discussion of a comparable 3,200-ton ship that could meet that requirement, and DOT&E did not differentiate between the two LCS designs, which are considerably different.

Neither LCS design has undergone Navy survivability tests, which are performed on all new ship classes.

A New Approach?If the LCS fails the tests, it is not clear what the next step would be. But whether the LCS is cut short or built out to 52 ships, the service already has been thinking about what a follow-on small combatant would look like.

Adm. Jonathan Greenert, chief of naval operations, routinely champions LCS, but already has directed the surface warfare community to begin thinking about a follow-on.

“We need to look and think about what the next small combatant is,” said Capt. Danny Hernandez, the CNO’s spokesman. “Regardless of what the number is going to be, there’s going to be something after LCS, and we need to look at our options. It’s also the prudent and responsible thing to do.”

One concept being thought about as an LCS alternative or follow-on has been a small frigate, able to defend several ships and provide escort services for merchant convoys, amphibious ships or support ships.

A capability gap already has been identified for an escort ship, said Bryan Clark, a naval analyst with the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments in Washington. Until last year, Clark also was a special assistant to Greenert, where he led the development of Navy strategy.

“The real need is for an escort to accompany convoys, logistic ships, even parts of the battle fleet. Analysis shows that as a gap. But LCS cannot provide air defense to ships it’s escorting — it only has self-defense,” Clark said.

“The Aegis destroyer is more than what is necessary for this mission. So this escort mission is one that cries out for a solution. That’s what a frigate can do,” he noted.

A frigate of about 4,100 tons, he said, would be a ship less capable than a 9,200-ton Aegis destroyer, but larger than the LCS.

“A frigate study would need to focus on designs that currently exist, that could be rapidly implemented at a US yard. And they’d probably include designs based on the LCS as well,” he said. “The study could include existing designs as well as starting from scratch. Foreign designs would be part of the mix — just as LCS is a derivative of foreign designs.”

Both LCS design teams, led by Lockheed Martin and Austal USA, have produced versions of their ships aimed at foreign sales, heavily loaded with permanently installed combat systems. Lockheed in particular is offering larger versions of its Freedom-class LCS, as well as smaller models.

“The Navy doesn’t really have an escort vessel that can do this mission. If you get into a large conflict you need to protect ships,” Clark said.

Key to that is effective anti-submarine warfare (ASW) and anti-air combat systems. The ASW mission package under development for LCS is getting early rave reviews from surface warfare officers, but the ships are too small to install Mark 41 vertical missile launchers needed for Standard anti-air missiles. An effective anti-air system also needs search and fire control radars, along with an expanded combat system.

“That’ll be the toughest part of the frigate study, trying to figure how to handle the air defense mission in a way that doesn’t involve the start of a new design,” Clark said.

Work on a new frigate is not being driven by OSD’s current efforts to cut back the LCS, Clark said, although it would provide a basis for a new ship should the LCS fail.

Work on future surface combat ships already is underway at the Pentagon by the director of surface warfare, and under the direction of the surface warfare commander in San Diego, but neither of those efforts is focused on a frigate. A new study, Clark said, would be aimed at a ship that could be developed within only a few years.

Regardless of the LCS debate, “this need was starting to emerge anyway,” he said. (Defensenews)

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    January 2016
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    4x4 Vehicle
    A109 LOH
    A 10 Warthog
    A10-warthog
    A330 MRTT
    A400M
    Aerostat
    AEW&C
    AFV
    AGM-114
    Agusta Westland Lynx AH9A
    AH 1Z
    AH-1Z
    AH 6
    AH-6
    AH 64E
    AH-64E
    Airbus
    Aircraft Carrier
    Air Defence Radar
    Air To Air Missile
    Akash SAM
    Altay MBT
    America
    Amphibious Combat Ship
    Angkatan Tentera Malaysia
    Anti Ship Missile
    Anti Tank
    Apache AH 64E
    Apache AH-64E
    APC
    APMM
    Article
    Artikel
    Artillery Systems
    ASAT
    ASEAN
    Asia Pacific Security Conference
    Assault Rifle
    ASTRIUM
    ASW
    ATM
    Attack Helicopter
    Australia
    AVIC
    BAE Systems
    Bay Class Patrol Boat
    Beijing
    Boeing
    Boeing 777-200ER
    Bomba
    Bombardier CL415
    Book Review/ Merchandising
    Border Security
    Brazil
    British Army
    BRP Artemio Ricarte
    Brunei
    C-130
    C-130 Hercules
    C17 Globemaster
    C-27J
    C 295
    C-295
    Casa
    CASEX
    CATIC
    China
    Close Air Support
    CMU
    Coastal Missile
    COPE TAUFAN
    Corvette
    CPMIEC
    Cruise Missile
    Customs Marine Unit
    Cyberwarfare
    Dassault
    Dassault Rafale
    Defence Exhibition
    Defense Forces Of Timor Leste.
    Denel
    Diaoyu
    DMZ
    DSA Exhibition
    DSCA
    EADS
    EC665 Tiger
    EC725
    Eks Angsa 9/2014
    Embraer
    ESSCOM
    ESSZONE
    Eurocopter Tigre
    Eurofighter Typhoon
    EX Cope Taufan
    EX Teak Mint
    F 15
    F-15
    F15 Eagle
    F 16
    F-16
    F22 Raptor
    F 35
    F-35
    F 5 Tiger
    F-5 Tiger
    F/A 18
    F/A-18
    Fast Attack Craft
    Fighter
    France
    Frigate
    GOF
    GOF Tiger Platoon
    Gowind Class
    Gripen
    GS Cargo
    Guest Column
    Gunship
    Haikou
    Hal
    Hanoi-class
    Hari Media
    Harpoon
    Hawk-100200
    Hellfire
    Howitzer
    IAF
    Iai
    IFV
    Illicit-arms-trade
    India
    Indian-army
    Indian-navy
    Indonesia
    Irst
    James-shoal
    Japan
    Japanese Defense Force
    Japan Maritime Self Defense Force
    JMSDF
    Joint Strike Missile
    Jsm
    Jsow
    Kai-t50i
    Kai-t-50i
    Kd-jebat
    Kd-kasturi
    Kd-kasturi-slep
    Kd-kedah-class
    Kd-pahang
    Kd-tunku-abdul-rahman
    Kd-tun-razak
    KH31
    Kiloclass
    Kilo-class
    Korps Marinir
    Kri-cakra
    Landing-helicopter-dock
    Leopard 2 MBT
    Liaoning
    Littoral-combat-ship
    Littoral Combat Ship (LCS)
    M346
    M-346
    Malaysia
    Malaysia-airlines-system
    Malaysia Ministry Of Defense
    Malaysian Maritime Enforcement Agency41d100b07f
    Manpads
    Marines
    Mbrl
    MBT
    Media Day
    Media Release
    MH370
    Mh60-seahawk
    Microsoft
    MiG 29
    MiG-29
    Military Exercises
    Mil-mi24
    Mil-mi-24
    Mil Mi- 8/ 17
    Mim104-patriot
    Minister Of Defense
    Missile
    Mmea
    Mmrca
    MPA
    MRCA
    Myanmar
    Nakhoda-ragam-class
    Naval-helicopter
    Naval Strike Missile
    News
    New Zealand
    Nh90
    Norway
    Novator-ks172
    NSM
    Oplot-mbt
    P3-orion
    P-8A Poseidon
    P-8a-poseidon
    P8a-poseidon
    Pag-asa-island
    Pagasa-island
    Pallada
    Paracel-islands
    Pars-av8
    Pasukan-udara-tentera-darat
    Patrol Vessel
    Patrol Vessel
    PDRM
    Peluru Berpandu
    Pengkalan-udara-gong-kedak
    Pesawat-tanpa-pemandu
    PGA
    Philippine
    Philippine Air Force
    Philippine Air Force
    Philippine Army
    Philippine Navy
    Philippines Air Force
    Philippines-navy
    PLAN
    Polis Diraja Malaysia
    Project 636
    PUTD
    Radar
    RAF
    Rafale
    RAN
    RBS-15
    Rbs15-mk-ii
    Rbs15-mk-iii
    Recep-tayyip-erdogan
    RMAF
    RMN
    Robot
    Robotsystem
    Roketsan
    Royal Australian Navy
    Royal-brunei-navy
    Royal Malaysian Airforce
    Royal-malaysian-air-force
    Royal Malaysian Navy
    Royal Malaysian Police
    Royal-navy
    Royal-thai-air-force
    Royal Thai Army
    Royal Thai Army
    Royal Thai Marine Corps
    Royal Thai Navy
    RSAF
    RSN
    Rss-archer
    Russia
    S-61
    S-61
    S61t
    S-61t
    Saab
    Sabah
    Satellite
    Scarborough-schoal
    Scorpene Class
    Sea
    Search-and-rescue
    Senkaku
    SGPV
    Siaran Media
    Sikorksy
    Singapore
    Singapore-air-show
    Singapore-armed-forces
    Singapore-navy
    Skynet
    Sonar
    South China Sea
    South-east-asia
    South Korea
    Spratly Island
    Starstreak
    St-engineering
    STRIDE
    Su27
    Su-27
    Su30
    Su-30
    Su30mki
    Su-30mki
    Su-30MKI
    SU-30MKM
    Submarine
    Sukhoi35
    Sukhoi-35
    Sultan-esmail-kiram-ii
    Sultan-jamalul-kiram-iii
    Sulu Sultanate
    Sulu Sultanate
    Super Tucano
    Surface-to-air-missile
    Sweden
    T 50 PAK FA
    T50-pak-fa
    T90
    Tai
    Taiwan
    Tank
    Targeting-pod
    Technicals
    Tender
    Tentera Darat
    Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia
    Tentera Udara Diraja Malaysia
    Terengganu
    Tfx
    Thailand
    The-center-for-a-new-american-security
    Tldm
    TNI
    TNI Angkatan Darat
    TNI-Angkatan Darat
    TNI Angkatan Laut
    TNI Angkatan Laut
    TNI Angkatan Udara
    Tokyo
    Toyota
    Trainer Aircraft
    Transport Aircraft
    Transport/ Utility Helicopter
    TUDM
    Turkey
    UAV
    UK MOD
    Ukraine
    United Kingdom
    United States Marine
    Upgrades
    Uralvagonzavod
    USAF
    US Army
    US Department Of Defense (DOD)
    USMC
    US Navy
    US Pacific Fleet
    US PACOM
    US PACOM
    V-22-osprey
    V22-osprey
    Varshavyanka-class
    Vietnam
    Vietnam Navy
    Weststar
    World-tour
    World-war-1
    Wuhan
    Xband-satellite
    Zhongye-island
    Zhuk-radar

    RSS Feed

    Disclaimer:
    All picture news and article are owned by the respective site and authors where the piece is instigated from. The owner of the news and article are acknowledged at each post and the piece is link back to their respective site. Pieces by Rentaka journalist and writer is copyrighted by Rentaka Advisory Enterprise and All Rights Reserve
    Copyright ©
    Rentaka Advisory Enterprise.
    All Right Reserved
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.